Anna Maria Island Nightlife & Cocktail Guide

Anna Maria Island is pure old-Florida charm, no high-rises, no chain restaurants, and definitely no rush. And while the vibe is laid-back, the island still pours a mean drink. Whether you’re barefoot in the sand with a rum runner or sipping wine with Gulf views, AMI serves its cocktails the same way it serves life, slow, sunny, and easy. Here are the island’s best spots to raise a glass.

The Sandbar Restaurant

Vibe: Toes-in-the-sand classic
A local legend, The Sandbar sits right on the beach and is famous for its sunset views. Order a mojito, a glass of wine, or a frozen concoction, sink your feet in the sand, and watch the sky do its nightly show.

The Waterfront Restaurant

Vibe: Relaxed but refined
Across from the City Pier, The Waterfront offers craft cocktails and a thoughtful wine list in a cozy, coastal-chic setting. Think jalapeño margaritas, refreshing mojitos, and fresh seafood to match.

Slim’s Place

Vibe: Sports bar with island soul
Slim’s is an island favorite for catching a game with a cold beer or a strong cocktail. It’s equal parts lively, casual, and welcoming—perfect for when you want a break from tiki drinks without losing the fun.

Hurricane Hanks

Vibe: Classic island bar & grill
Known for its hearty pub food and friendly service, Hurricane Hanks also mixes up a solid cocktail and keeps the taps flowing with local craft beers. Great for a casual night out with friends or family.

Beach Bistro

Vibe: Upscale romance with a view
If you’re looking for a refined night, Beach Bistro is the move. Their wine list is one of the best on the island, the cocktails are crafted with care, and the Gulf-front setting is as romantic as it gets.

Harry’s Grill

Vibe: Old-school island fun
Harry’s is a longtime staple with a full bar, strong pours, and frequent live music. It’s the kind of place where you wander in for “just one” and stay way longer than planned.

Anna Maria Oyster Bar (AMOB Pier)

Vibe: Dockside sips
On the Bridge Street Pier, AMOB delivers waterfront drinks, seafood baskets, and the breezy feel of Old Florida. Frozen daiquiris, rum runners, and beers by the bucket are the moves here.

Insider Tip

AMI is seven miles long, and the free trolley makes it easy to hop from bar to bar without driving. Plan your crawl north-to-south (or vice versa), ending with a sunset toast at The Sandbar or AMOB on the pier.