Local Restaurants
Fork Yeah: Our favorite local eats.
Siesta Key - Local Restaurants
From beachside tacos to melt-in-your-mouth pasta, these are the spots we keep going back to, or seriously regret not trying (yet).
Siesta Key
The Cottage - 5mins
Located in the heart of Siesta Key Village, The Cottage offers inventive, seasonal cuisine with a global twist. It has a relaxed island atmosphere, with live music.
Big Water Fish Market - 7mins
Known for its fresh seafood offerings in a casual setting. Check out the shrimp tacos and fish and chips.
Siesta Key Oyster Bar - 5mins
A staple in Siesta Key Village, SKOB is renowned for its fresh oysters, cold beer, and live music. The laid-back, beachy vibe, complete with dollar bills adorning the walls, creates a fun and welcoming atmosphere.
Summer House Steak & Seafood - 5mins
For an upscale dining experience, Summer House offers carefully sourced steaks and fresh seafood in an elegant yet relaxed setting. Their hand-selected wines complement the menu, making it ideal for special occasions.
Ophelia’s on the Bay - 12mins
Situated on the waterfront, Ophelia’s provides a romantic dining experience with stunning views of Little Sarasota Bay. The menu features fresh, seasonal ingredients, with dishes like Alaskan halibut and eggplant crepes receiving high praise.
Island House Tap & Grill - 4mins
This spot is perfect for those seeking a variety of craft beers and delicious pub fare. With options like ahi tuna tacos and a diverse beer selection, it's a great place to relax after a day at the beach.
Captain Curt’s Crab & Oyster Bar - 7mins
A family-run establishment since 1979, Captain Curt’s is famous for its clam chowder and fresh oysters. The casual, friendly environment makes it a great spot for families and groups.
Downtown Sarasota
Duval’s Fresh. Local. Seafood. - 16mins
A local favorite. Signature dishes include the spiced-rubbed corvina and shrimp po’boys. The restaurant also offers a complimentary shuttle service within the downtown area.
1592 Wood Fired Kitchen & Cocktails - 15mins
This Mediterranean-inspired eatery features a wood-fired grill, delivering bold flavors in dishes like lamb kofta and wood-fired octopus.
Beso - 15mins
An upscale tapas restaurant offering a modern take on Spanish classics.
Indigenous - 15mins
Helmed by Chef Steve Phelps, this restaurant emphasizes sustainable, locally sourced ingredients. The ever-changing menu showcases seasonal dishes, with a particular focus on Gulf seafood.
Selva Grill - 16mins
A sophisticated spot specializing in Peruvian cuisine with a modern twist. Highlights include the wahoo ceviche and tuna tiradito.
Café Epicure - 16mins
This Italian trattoria offers a relaxed setting with a menu featuring classic pasta dishes, pizzas, and a well-curated wine list.
Mattison’s City Grille - 16mins
An open-air restaurant known for its live music and diverse menu, including tapas, pasta, and seafood dishes. It's a great spot for casual dining and people-watching.
Caragiulos - 15mins
A family-owned Italian-American restaurant offering comfort food favorites like lasagna, linguine with clam sauce, and house-made focaccia. The vintage Italian movie posters add to its charming ambiance.
The Breakfast House - 15mins
A cozy spot famous for its pancakes and hearty breakfast platters. The "Uncle Harry’s hearty breakfast" is a must-try for those seeking a filling start to their day.