Best Places to Eat on Anna Maria Island

Anna Maria Island may only stretch seven miles long, but its food scene packs a punch. The island’s got it all: beachy shacks serving grouper sandwiches on paper plates, upscale Gulf-front dining that rivals any foodie city, and plenty of “where the locals go” spots in between. Whether you’re looking for flip-flop casual or linen-napkin refined, here’s where to eat on AMI.

Rod & Reel Pier

Vibe: Old Florida, no frills
This little wooden pier restaurant is a true island treasure. Don’t expect white tablecloths—expect fried fish baskets, cold beer, and some of the best water views on the island. Come for the grouper sandwich, stay for the “feels like home” vibe.

Ginny’s & Jane E’s Café and Gift Store

Vibe: Funky, artsy, and very AMI
Part café, part quirky gift shop, Ginny’s & Jane E’s is as colorful as the island itself. Go for breakfast or lunch and don’t skip the cinnamon rolls—they’re famous for a reason.

The Sandbar Restaurant

Vibe: Toes in the sand dining
One of AMI’s most iconic spots, The Sandbar serves Gulf-to-table seafood with a side of epic sunsets. It’s the kind of place you bring visitors to show off the island. Order the grouper tacos or a seafood platter, and thank us later.

The Waterfront Restaurant

Vibe: Coastal chic without the fuss
Across from the City Pier, this restaurant nails that balance of casual island atmosphere with thoughtful, creative dishes. Fresh fish, island-inspired cocktails, and a menu that rotates with the seasons make it a standout.

Skinny’s Place

Vibe: Burger shack heaven
A true hole-in-the-wall, Skinny’s is a no-frills burger joint across from the Manatee Public Beach. Burgers, cold beer in mason jars, picnic tables, and beach vibes—it doesn’t get more “classic Florida” than this.

Beach Bistro

Vibe: Upscale Gulf-front dining
If you want to dress up a little and splurge, Beach Bistro is the island’s fine dining star. Known for its intimate setting and award-winning menu, it’s where to go for anniversary dinners, romantic nights, or when you want to impress.

Hurricane Hanks

Vibe: Casual pub with island flavor
A relaxed spot for comfort food—think fish and chips, sandwiches, and cold beers. It’s where locals gather, especially when they want hearty food without fuss.

Anna Maria Oyster Bar (AMOB Pier)

Vibe: Waterfront classic
Perched on the Bridge Street Pier, AMOB serves seafood platters, fried favorites, and oysters, of course. It’s casual, family-friendly, and comes with salty breezes and dolphin sightings.

Harry’s Continental Kitchens (technically Longboat, but a quick drive)

Vibe: Gourmet island staple
Many AMI locals cross the bridge to Harry’s for a change of pace. From creative brunch to refined dinners, Harry’s is worth the detour.

Insider Tip

Mix your meals: start the day with a cinnamon roll at Ginny’s & Jane E’s, grab a burger at Skinny’s for lunch, and finish with sunset seafood at The Sandbar. That’s the AMI trifecta right there.